Friday, 11 January 2013

Dismissal of Appeal on Non Prosecution

  Citation Name  : 2012  SCMR  1235     SUPREME-COURT
  Side Appellant : BABAR HUSSAIN SHAH
  Side Opponent : MUJEEB AHMED KHAN
Art. 168---Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908), O.XLI, R.19---Readmission of an appeal dismissed for non-prosecution ---Limitation---Determination---Re-listing of appeal in different High Court---No notice issued to the defendant of such re-listing---Effect---Appeal filed by the defendant (respondent) transferred from the (Lahore) High Court to (Islamabad) High Court without giving any notice to the defendant or his counsel---Appeal re-listed in the (Islamabad) High Court after directions to the office to issue notice to the defendant and his counsel---No such notice issued---Appeal dismissed for "non-prosecution " due to non-presence of the defendant and his counsel---Application of defendant for restoration of his appeal and condonation of delay was allowed by the (Islamabad) High Court through the impugned judgment---Validity---(Islamabad) High Court had directed the office to re-list the case (appeal) after issuance of notice to the defendant and his counsel, but the office re-fixed the case without issuing notices---Where during the hearing of a case, a date was given in the presence of a counsel, then his non-appearance could be taken notice of and the case could be dismissed for non-prosecution but where date was not given in his presence and his name did not appear in the cause list then an order for dismissal for non-prosecution would not be considered to be legal---In the present case, although the name of the counsel who filed his 'Vakalatnama' in the (Lahore) High Court on behalf of the defendant, appeared in the cause list but same was no consequence because the 'Vakalatnama' was given to appear befor e the (Lahore) High Court and not befor e (Islamabad) High Court---Issuance of notice to the defendant was necessary befor e the case could be dismissed for non-prosecution ---Order of (Islamabad) High Court by which it dismissed the appeal for non-prosecution had been passed in complete violation of the rules of natural justice and void---Supreme Court directoral the Islamabad High Court to treat the matter pending and fix the same for hearing after issuance of notices to all the parties. 
http://pakistanlawsite.com/LawOnline/law/images/headnotes_01.png http://pakistanlawsite.com/LawOnline/law/images/casedescri_01.png http://pakistanlawsite.com/LawOnline/law/images/bookmark_01.png